In a surprising move, the Girl Scouts of the USA have announced that the popular ‘Toast-Yay!’ and ‘S’mores’ cookie varieties will be discontinued starting in the 2025 cookie season. The decision has left many loyal fans of the cookies disappointed, as these flavors were among the most sought-after during cookie sales.
The organization stated, “We understand how much our cookie fans love these unique flavors, but due to supply chain issues and changing consumer preferences, we are refocusing our product lineup to ensure the continuation of our most popular cookies.” This announcement comes as the Girl Scouts aim to optimize their selection and navigate challenges stemming from inflation and production.
The Girl Scout Cookies program has been a staple of American culture, with millions of boxes sold each year, contributing to the funding of various community and leadership programs for young girls. The top-selling varieties, including Thin Mints and Girl Scout S’mores, will remain available, but the discontinuation of ‘Toast-Yay!’—championed for its maple flavor—and ‘S’mores’—beloved for its graham cracker and chocolate combination—marks a significant shift.
Fans have taken to social media to express their disappointment, with many calling for the cookies to be kept in production. Some have even started petitions to bring them back for the next cookie season, highlighting the emotional connection to these flavors. As the 2025 cookie season approaches, cookie enthusiasts will have to say goodbye to these beloved treats.
